Angelica disappeared from El Monte, California on November 23, 1985. The circumstances of her disappearance are unclear. In 1985, Angelica was in junior high school and dating an older boyfriend, and she and her father got into a fight about it before she left the house. Her father and stepmother thought she'd just gone to a neighborhood friend's home and would return after she'd calmed down, but she never came back. The police went to her friend's home, but there was no one there; the family had apparently moved. Angelica has never been seen or heard from again. Her father and stepmother still live in the same house in the hopes that she will come back to her old address. Angelica has a scar under her right eye. Her upper left front tooth was chipped at the time of her 1985 disappearance. Her nickname is Angel.