Lindsey was last seen leaving his Hiddenite, North Carolina residence on June 1, 1989. He went to a party with a friend, who later said he dropped Lindsey off in the Bethlehem, Noth Carolina area. His friend couldn't remember the specific location or address, however. Lindsey has never been heard from again. Few details are available in his case. Lindsey has a mole on his left cheek and another mole between his eyebrows, and a birthmark in the middle of his back. His nicknames are Junior and Booter. He had a mustache and shoulder-length hair at the time of his disappearance.