DiCenso was last seen in the vicinity of Belvedere Avenue southeast in Warren, Ohio on May 7, 2014. She was in a gray SUV with an unidentified Caucasian female and African-American female at the time. She lived on South Street southeast at the time of her disappearance. Her daughter, Danielle Lindic, reported her missing on May 9. Foul play is suspected in DiCenso's case, as it's uncharacteristic of her to leave without warning. One theory is that she became a victim of sex trafficking. Her disappearance may be drug-related.