Suzanne and her friend Stacy McCall planned to stay at a hotel in Branson, Missouri overnight. Stacy and Suzanne left their friend's residence after the police were summoned due to a noise complaint. They decided to stay at Suzanne's home for the rest of the night. The girls drove their separate vehicles back to the residence. The girls arrived at approximately 2:15 a.m. on June 7. Neither they nor Sherrill have been heard from again. Neighbors did not hear any suspicious activity near Sherrill's home during the overnight hours. All of the women's personal belongings were discovered inside the house; their vehicles were also parked at the home. Their cases remain unsolved.